For those who remember a time before the internet was in everyone’s pocket, the term “Bug Out Bag” (BOB) might have sounded like something out of a science fiction novel. Today, it’s a common term, a reflection of our increasingly uncertain world. Walk into any social gathering, and you’ll likely find a good number of people familiar with the concept of a pre-packed emergency kit.
However, a crucial aspect often overlooked is tailoring your BOB to the environment you’re most likely to face during an emergency. Is your bug out scenario unfolding in a densely populated urban area, or a remote rural setting? Many survival guides offer generic BOB checklists, but treating urban and rural environments the same is like sending a handyman to fix your house with a single, generic toolbox, no matter if it’s a plumbing or electrical issue!
This article won’t rehash the standard bug out bag contents – we assume you’re already familiar with the basics (if not, CLICK HERE for a customizable BOB checklist delivered straight to your inbox!). Instead, we’ll delve into the critical differences in gear selection when preparing for urban versus rural bug out scenarios. While some essentials remain constant, the optimal tools for survival in a concrete jungle versus the wilderness vary significantly.
Choosing the Right Tools for the Job: Urban vs. Rural Survival
Generic advice on bug out bag essentials often fails to consider the vastly different environments where these bags might be deployed. Imagine facing an emergency in a bustling city with a kit designed for wilderness survival – or vice versa. Having the wrong tools isn’t just inconvenient; it can be life-threatening.
Drawing from over two decades of law enforcement experience in the Los Angeles metropolitan area, I’ve witnessed firsthand the types of crises that unfold in urban and suburban settings. From accidents to intentional acts of violence, these incidents, unfortunately, are likely to escalate and become widespread during and after major disasters. Crucially, two factors will be amplified:
- Magnitude: The scale of these incidents will be exponentially larger, overwhelming typical emergency response capabilities.
- Resource Scarcity: Available resources, including emergency services, will be stretched thin or entirely inaccessible.
Adding to the danger, a severe disaster impacting infrastructure and emergency response can create a synergistic effect. Predatory individuals and groups will likely recognize the reduced law enforcement presence faster than the general public and exploit the situation early on. While we hope this is not the case, preparedness demands acknowledging this potential reality.
Disaster Planning: Know Your Environment – Urban vs. Rural
Developing a Bug Out Plan tailored to your specific location is paramount. Your plan should incorporate the unique challenges and potential hazards inherent to your area of operation.
Urban Disaster Planning: Prioritizing Escape and Evasion
In an urban environment crippled by a catastrophic event, immediate evacuation from densely populated areas should be the primary objective. This urgency is a key differentiator from rural bug outs, where time might be less critical initially. Urban BOBs must prioritize rapid movement and obstacle negation. Therefore, your urban BOB preparation should focus on:
- Navigation in Chaos: Equip yourself to identify and utilize alternate routes on the fly, adapting to rapidly changing urban landscapes.
- Overcoming Urban Obstacles: Possess tools to bypass or overcome physical barriers commonly found in cities, like debris, locked gates, or structural damage.
- Extrication Capabilities, Including Car Escape Tools: Include tools to free yourself or others from entrapment due to structural collapse, vehicle accidents, or other urban-specific confinement scenarios. This is where a high-quality car escape tool, such as the Resqme car escape tool (Https Www.thebugoutbagguide.com Best-car-escape-tool), becomes indispensable. These compact tools can be attached to keychains or kept in the car, providing immediate access to a window breaker and seatbelt cutter, crucial for escaping a vehicle after a crash or in a flood.
- Breaching Interior Walls: Have the means to create escape routes through interior walls if trapped within buildings, evading threats inside.
- Effective Self-Defense: If avoidance fails, be prepared to defend against violent attacks.
Rural Disaster Planning: Shelter, Sustenance, and Long-Term Survival
Rural or wilderness survival scenarios, especially short-term ones, prioritize different needs:
- Firecraft: Capability to process wood efficiently for starting and maintaining fires for warmth, cooking, and signaling.
- Shelter Construction: Means to create basic, short-term shelter from the elements.
- Resource Acquisition (Optional): For longer-term scenarios, tools to fashion crude hunting devices or other aids for resource gathering might be considered.
CONFIG_leads_shortcode{“id”:”4973″}CONFIG_leads_shortcode
Urban (and Suburban) Bug Out Bag Essentials
Maps and Navigation
A detailed city map, covering both your home and work locations, is crucial. Urban environments after a disaster become fluid and unpredictable, demanding rapid route adjustments to avoid danger. Even with excellent combat skills, avoiding conflict is always preferable. Evasive maneuvers in a city can quickly lead to disorientation. Pack a map! Include at least two reliable light sources for nighttime map reading. Unlike wilderness navigation, a simple, inexpensive compass is generally sufficient for city map orientation.
Click on the image to brush up on your map reading skills. Essential for both urban and rural bug out scenarios.
Low-Profile Appearance
In contrast to wilderness trekking, sporting high-end, “tacticool” gear in a disaster-stricken urban area is a liability. Drawing unwanted attention from opportunistic predators is the last thing you need. Experienced criminals are surprisingly adept at spotting quality gear, even if they don’t recognize the specific items.
Minimize your visibility. While carrying a pack is unavoidable, opt for a worn, unassuming civilian-style backpack rather than a brand-new tactical one. Similarly, choose plain, practical clothing and footwear. Mastering “Gray Man/Woman” skills is vital for blending in and reducing your target profile during urban emergencies (Click HERE to learn how).
Click on the image to learn how to be a Gray Man or Woman. Essential for minimizing attention and staying safe in urban disaster scenarios.
Tomahawk Over Large Knife: Urban Breaching Tool
My experience as a first responder has shown me the practical tools needed in urban emergencies. Beyond standard weapons and medical gear, tools designed for breaching urban barriers – car doors, windows, security doors – are frequently essential.
While you might hope to avoid assisting others during a bug out, unforeseen circumstances might require you to help yourself or someone else. Moreover, in an urban setting, breaching and creating escape routes within buildings becomes a significant preparedness factor, especially with rising concerns about terrorism and active shooter incidents.
This leads to the argument for prioritizing a rugged tomahawk over a large survival knife in an urban BOB. Despite the common advice of including a large knife in every BOB, a tomahawk is far more versatile and effective for urban scenarios. Affordable and robust tomahawks are readily available, often at half the cost of a survival knife with comparable capabilities beyond basic cutting.
The Estwing Black Eagle Tomahawk exemplifies this. While not aesthetically refined, its functionality is undeniable. I’ve personally used its spike to breach car windows, penetrate steel mesh and car trunks, and even break through concrete blocks (though without encountering rebar). It’s also effective for prying apart nailed lumber. After such use, the tomahawk’s edge shows only cosmetic wear. Could a survival knife endure such tasks without damage or breakage? Unlikely.
Knives, even high-quality ones, are not designed for breaching hardened materials like steel, concrete, or glass. Remember the officer who damaged his $250 tanto knife attempting to repeatedly punch through a steel locker door? For urban barrier penetration, the tomahawk reigns supreme. Learn more about choosing the right tomahawk in our article on Picking The Best Tomahawk For Your Bug Out Bag HERE.
Click on the image above to learn how to pick the best tomahawk for your bug out bag.
While I have no affiliation with Estwing, and other comparable tomahawks may exist at similar price points (around $35 HERE on Amazon), the Estwing has proven its worth. Lighter tomahawks with plastic handles often lack the necessary performance. The Estwing’s only drawback is its weight at 27 ounces. While the popular Becker BK2 survival knife is lighter by 10 ounces, the tomahawk’s breaching capability justifies the added weight in an urban BOB.
Combined with a multi-tool (essential for any BOB; see our Guide for Picking The Best Multi Tool HERE), a robust tomahawk provides a comprehensive cutlery setup for urban survival. The tomahawk handles heavy-duty tasks, while the multi-tool’s blade tackles finer cutting needs. If a dedicated knife is desired for traditional cutting chores, a Mora Kniv is an excellent, budget-friendly option, adding minimal weight.
Finally, a tomahawk can serve as a last-resort self-defense tool. While neither a tomahawk nor a knife is ideal for self-defense (a topic for another discussion), a tomahawk can be effectively employed in a pinch.
Lightweight Wire Cutters
The ability to quickly cut through chain-link fences can be critical for escaping dangerous situations, seeking shelter, or shortening travel time in urban environments. Chain-link fencing is ubiquitous in cities. Unfortunately, multi-tool wire cutters often prove inadequate for quickly cutting through chain-link. Invest in a small, lightweight tool specifically designed for chain-link, like the Tekton 8-inch Heavy-Duty Wire Cutter (see them HERE). Bending or sawing through wire is too slow and cumbersome in urgent situations.
Rural / Wilderness Bug Out Bag Essentials
Knife, Hatchet, or Tomahawk: Wood Processing Focus
While we advocated for a tomahawk in urban settings, the tool priorities shift in rural/wilderness environments. Having spent considerable time in wilderness areas, including multi-day solo trips and search & rescue operations in the California Sierras, I favor a large knife in non-urban settings.
Historically, tomahawks served multiple purposes, only one of which was wood processing. Hatchets (hand axes), conversely, were designed specifically for wood work. As expected, hatchets outperform tomahawks in wood processing, while tomahawks excel as weapons. Despite trying various “woods hawks,” I’ve found that quality hatchets of similar weight are simply more efficient for wood-related tasks.
Considering the disaster planning priorities outlined earlier, a hatchet is a strong contender for a rural BOB.
However, my personal preference for a rural BOB leans towards a large survival knife over a hatchet. While hatchets chop wood more efficiently than knives of comparable weight, this isn’t the complete picture. For cutting wood, a small, lightweight folding saw is often superior to chopping. And crucially, the primary step in firewood preparation is splitting wood for fire starting.
A quality knife with a 7- to 9-inch blade excels at splitting wood using the “batoning” technique. In my experience, batoning is also a safer wood-splitting method than swinging a hatchet, especially in cold conditions. Concerns about batoning being abusive to the blade are largely unfounded. I’ve split at least a cord of wood with my Ontario SP50, and it remains in excellent working condition, despite some coating wear. Watch a video on batoning techniques to see it in action.
Many quality survival knives rival the Estwing in wood processing capabilities. For a wilderness BOB fixed blade, opt for a 7-inch or longer blade to facilitate splitting larger diameter wood. Consult our comprehensive guide on choosing fixed blades CLICK HERE NOW.
High-Quality Compass
Navigating areas without street signs or roads demands a superior compass. Land navigation in such terrain, using topographical maps, is an advanced skill. When possible, stick to roads or keep them in sight. However, a rural BOB must include a high-quality compass.
Redundant Fire Starting Kit
A fire starting kit is non-negotiable. In urban bug outs, fire may be a double-edged sword, attracting unwanted attention while potentially deterring wildlife. However, in wilderness settings, fire is paramount for warmth, cooking, signaling, and psychological comfort.
For rural/wilderness BOBs, multiple fire-starting methods are a must:
Include petroleum jelly-soaked cotton balls; they ignite easily with a spark and burn for several minutes, even in damp conditions. Learn six fire-starting methods without matches CLICK HERE.
Steel Water Bottle for Boiling
Every BOB needs a water container. Opt for a single-walled stainless steel water bottle like the Klean Kanteen (or similar). These can be placed directly over flames or coals to boil water.
Boiling water is a reliable method to eliminate waterborne pathogens (pathogen removal information). I once used a heated steel water bottle as an improvised hot water bottle in a snow cave to combat hypothermia – potentially a lifesaver. Always remove the cap before heating to prevent pressure buildup and explosion.
Conclusion: Tailor Your BOB to Your Terrain
My experience underscores the importance of rapid urban evacuation in a SHTF scenario. Sheltering in place in a city is likely to be disastrous. A robust tomahawk, multi-tool, and wire cutters form a near-perfect urban BOB toolset – though innovation may bring further improvements. Don’t forget to include a dedicated car escape tool like the Resqme (https www.thebugoutbagguide.com best-car-escape-tool) for vehicle-related emergencies in urban environments.
CONFIG_leads_shortcode{“id”:”4973″}CONFIG_leads_shortcode
Rural/wilderness survival prioritizes overnight sheltering and firecraft. Night travel is less desirable. A large survival knife becomes the most versatile and safest tool for wilderness treks, surpassing both tomahawks and hatchets in overall utility.
Simply having a bug out bag, even if not perfectly optimized, places you far ahead of most. Preparedness, in any form, is 90% of the battle. However, regularly evaluating your gear choices with a clear understanding of your potential environment is crucial for maximizing your survival chances.
Ready to build your custom Bug Out Bag List? Click the button above now.
Further Reading
For more in-depth information on this topic, explore these resources:
Your Thoughts?
What “must-have” items do you include in your urban or rural bug out bag? Can you identify other key differences in gear selection for these environments? Share your insights in the comments below!
About The Author
Frank LaFlamme is a veteran of law enforcement in the Los Angeles area, with nearly 25 years of service across multiple agencies, including a DEA assignment. His experience spans uniformed patrol in high-crime areas, narcotics and gang enforcement, robbery and homicide investigations, high-risk warrant service, and terrorism liaison roles. Post-retirement, Frank volunteered as a Search & Rescue operative in the Sierra Nevada Mountains and established F&D Consulting, a disaster preparedness consulting firm. In 2014, he authored the novel “EMP Los Angeles” (an Amazon bestseller for a period, CLICK HERE to see it), a gripping and realistic portrayal of a post-EMP Los Angeles.
Click on the book to explore it on Amazon!
[
