The digital age holds immense potential to revolutionize healthcare, particularly for historically underserved, low-resource, and remote communities. A pivotal virtual workshop convened by the NHLBI in April 2021 brought together experts to explore how technology can effectively improve heart, lung, blood, and sleep health within these populations. The central focus was identifying accessible and practical technological solutions for disease diagnosis and Disease Management Vs Care Management Tools, aiming to pinpoint high-impact innovations and areas ripe for further investigation. This article delves into the key discussions and insights from this workshop, highlighting the critical role of technology in bridging the health equity gap.
Technology, Diagnostic Tools, and Metrics for Equitable Healthcare
The Digital Divide: Internet Access as a Foundational Barrier
A recurring theme throughout the workshop was the stark reality of limited broadband internet access in underserved communities. This digital divide acts as a significant barrier to deploying many health-related technologies that depend on robust internet connectivity. The unfortunate correlation between inequities in healthcare access and internet access underscores the urgency of addressing this infrastructural gap. Achieving health equity necessitates sustained initiatives to expand internet access for underserved populations. In the interim, employing diverse communication methods, such as telephone consultations and in-person outreach, can provide crucial alternatives for those with restricted internet availability.
Integrated Technology Solutions for Holistic Care Management
Moving beyond individual tools, the discussion emphasized the need for seamless integration of various technologies and platforms. This includes point-of-care devices, wearable sensors, app-based patient interfaces, and comprehensive digital health ecosystems. Such integration is vital for delivering continuous, real-time health data, enabling proactive and personalized care management tools. Effective technology solutions must adopt a patient-centric approach, adapting to individual needs, facilitating clear communication, and addressing the interconnected social determinants of health that significantly impact overall well-being.
Electronic Health Records: Centralizing Data for Enhanced Disease Management
The workshop highlighted the transformative potential of incorporating data collected outside traditional clinical settings into Electronic Health Records (EHRs). This integration can redefine the landscape of access to care and point-of-care delivery. By consolidating a broader spectrum of patient-generated health information, EHRs can become powerful disease management tools, providing a more complete picture of a patient’s health status and enabling more informed and timely interventions.
Standardized Metrics: Measuring Impact and Ensuring Comparability in Disease Management
The development and adoption of common metrics are essential for evaluating the effectiveness of healthcare programs and interventions, particularly when leveraging technology. Standardized metrics allow for consistent assessment of health outcomes, program impact, and comparability across different initiatives as technology and methodologies evolve. These metrics must be meaningful and relevant to the specific needs and priorities of underserved populations. Engaging all stakeholders, especially the communities themselves, in the selection of metrics, particularly for value-based metrics that assess quality of care, is crucial. Collaboration with organizations like the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) is vital to ensure that clinical quality data and patient-generated data are effectively measured and utilized to incentivize data-driven quality control and improvement in disease management and care management.
Accessible Diagnostics: Lessons from the Pandemic for Future Disease Management
The COVID-19 pandemic served as a catalyst for rapid innovation in accessible diagnostics. The swift development and widespread deployment of affordable and accessible testing platforms for COVID-19 demonstrated the feasibility of rapidly creating and distributing similar tools for other health conditions. This experience offers valuable insights for developing accessible diagnostic solutions to identify patients who could benefit from emerging therapies and proactive disease management strategies. Ensuring access to fundamental diagnostic tools remains paramount, even as we strive for more advanced capabilities, enabling effective monitoring of treatment efficacy and efficiency in the future.
App-Based and Point-of-Care Technologies: Empowering Patients and Communities
Patient-Operated Platforms: Tailoring Apps for User Engagement in Care Management
App-based platforms have emerged as powerful care management tools, offering direct engagement and personalized support for patients. However, their effectiveness hinges on intuitive design that caters to the specific needs of diverse users. Cultural sensitivity and language accessibility are paramount to ensure user adoption and engagement. The accuracy of mobile apps can vary based on user demographics, with studies indicating potential limitations in accuracy among older patients. Conversely, wearable monitors and sensor devices present a cost-effective means for continuous health status monitoring, intervention tracking, and outcome evaluation. Text-based behavioral interventions, when appropriately tailored, have shown promise in reaching diverse communities, offering scalable and accessible support. Digital health platforms play a central role in integrating test results from various sources, including lateral flow assays (LFAs), wearable data, and patient-reported symptoms, streamlining data management and enhancing disease management workflows. The widespread adoption of smartphones positions them as essential tools for data collection, information dissemination, remote healthcare access, and enhanced communication within the healthcare ecosystem.
Point-of-Care Technologies: Expanding Access to Underserved Communities for Disease Management
Point-of-Care (POC) technologies hold immense potential to extend healthcare reach to underserved communities, enabling efficient screening, diagnosis, and treatment monitoring closer to patients’ homes. Examples of impactful POC technologies include:
- POC blood tests for hemoglobin levels: Crucial for managing anemia and sickle cell disease, these tests offer rapid and accessible diagnostic capabilities.
- Portable systems and monitors: Devices like portable oxygen delivery systems and home sleep monitoring tools (e.g., for obstructive sleep apnea diagnosis and home polysomnography) empower patients to manage their health conditions in the comfort of their homes, providing ecologically valid sleep data and improving disease management for chronic conditions.
- Telehealth visits: Telehealth consultations serve as a form of POC assessment, allowing providers to remotely evaluate patient conditions, observe social determinants of health, conduct medication reconciliation, and deliver timely care management.
- Electronic inhaler monitoring systems: These innovative devices provide objective, real-time data on medication adherence for respiratory conditions, identifying overuse, missed doses, and deviations from prescribed regimens, thus optimizing disease management for conditions like asthma and COPD.
Telemedicine and Telehealth Services: Transforming Healthcare Delivery for Disease Management
The COVID-19 pandemic triggered a dramatic surge in telemedicine adoption, demonstrating its viability as a crucial component of modern healthcare delivery. However, disparities in access to video visits, particularly among African Americans, Hispanics, and older adults (over 65), highlight existing digital divides and technology literacy gaps. Challenges to widespread telemedicine adoption include limited broadband access, varying levels of technology literacy, physician training and acceptance of telemedicine, and complex billing issues.
Pre-pandemic limitations on telehealth reimbursement have been significantly addressed. Health centers funded by the HRSA expanded their telehealth services during the pandemic, and CMS reimbursement enhancements facilitated the continued provision of care through telehealth. Ongoing efforts by the FCC and other federal agencies, alongside broadband providers, aim to improve broadband access, potentially transforming telehealth accessibility and impacting disease management and care management in underserved areas. Significant public investment in broadband infrastructure further underscores the commitment to leveraging telehealth for equitable healthcare delivery.
Return on Investment and Regulatory Pathways for Sustainable Innovation
The development of technology solutions specifically tailored for underserved populations often faces challenges related to return on investment for private companies. This makes public sector investment all the more critical to foster innovation and facilitate the development and implementation of equitable healthcare technologies. Furthermore, unclear regulatory pathways and reimbursement models can hinder the adoption and scalability of these solutions. Navigating patent protection complexities also presents a challenge. Addressing these systemic barriers is crucial to incentivize innovation and ensure the sustainable development and deployment of technologies that can effectively address health disparities through improved disease management and care management tools.
Community Engagement and Addressing Health Disparities
Sustained Community Partnerships: The Cornerstone of Equitable Healthcare Innovation
Meaningful and sustained partnerships with communities are paramount for driving impactful innovation and ensuring the successful implementation of healthcare solutions in underserved populations. These partnerships are fundamental to tackling health disparities and require dedicated investment of time, effort, and resources to cultivate trust, understand community-specific needs, and build strong, collaborative relationships. Key principles for successful community engagement include:
- Engagement as Equal Partnership: Recognizing diverse and underserved individuals as equal partners in research and innovation processes, fostering research capacity within historically excluded communities.
- Meaningful Communication and Connection: Establishing and maintaining open communication channels, providing ongoing coaching and support for both researchers and community partners, and utilizing diverse communication strategies to accommodate varied partner needs and preferences.
- Building Trust: Recognizing trust as the bedrock of effective partnerships. Addressing mistrust of medicine and research within underserved communities is crucial for improving recruitment, enrollment, and the translation of research findings into tangible community benefits. Data utilization must be transparent and beneficial to the specific community to foster trust in data collection and use. Partnering with community leaders and advocates is essential to address issues of trust and distrust proactively.
- Community-Based Approach: Meeting underserved populations within their own communities, acknowledging and respecting community leaders as integral to the research continuum.
- Leveraging Trusted Brokers: Recognizing the role of gatekeepers and trusted brokers within communities and understanding their perspectives on health equity, aligning efforts to leverage opportunities they identify for community improvement.
- Community Uniqueness: Acknowledging the diversity and unique experiences, perceptions, and needs of each community, avoiding generalizations and tailoring approaches accordingly.
- Workforce Development: Investing in workforce development to sustain community relationships and conduct community-responsive research, including supporting junior investigators focused on health equity research, community champions, and community health workers.
- Research Culture Transformation: Recognizing that traditional research culture may not always incentivize or adequately support community engagement and power-sharing. Advocating for institutional changes within NIH and academic institutions to better support community partnerships within typical grant cycles.
- Tribal Sovereignty: Recognizing tribal nations as sovereign entities and respecting tribal governance structures, seeking approvals from tribal leaders and elders and engaging them as research partners.
- Accelerating Innovation through Diversity: Prioritizing research topics relevant to underserved communities, increasing diversity among researchers, and actively recruiting diverse study participants to accelerate innovation and ensure relevance.
- Community Health Workers as Key Enablers: Recognizing the pivotal role of community health workers in bridging gaps, addressing social determinants of health, providing health education, and improving access to care through patient navigation, while acknowledging the service-intensive nature of this approach.
Social Determinants of Health: Addressing Root Causes of Health Disparities
Disparities in health outcomes are inextricably linked to social determinants of health. Healthcare payment models must incorporate these factors to prevent exacerbating existing disparities and biases. Workshop participants identified key challenges and opportunities related to social determinants of health:
-
Challenges:
- The inherent difficulty and potential infeasibility of altering deeply entrenched unhealthy living conditions.
- Limited access to nearby specialty care and privacy concerns associated with collecting sensitive health information.
- Geographical and social isolation contributing to mental health issues like depression, which can worsen chronic health conditions and impede effective disease management.
-
Opportunities:
- Leveraging technology to connect patients with local resources addressing basic needs, such as access to healthy foods, safe housing, and employment opportunities, as crucial care management tools.
- Empowering community health workers to facilitate access to essential services and resources, build trust regarding privacy concerns, and provide technology training to enhance digital literacy and improve disease management and care management.
- Evolving payer policies to allow reimbursement for health technology devices, recognizing their role in addressing social determinants of health and improving outcomes. Precision health approaches hold promise for integrating social needs into clinical diagnostics and disease management strategies, fostering more holistic and equitable care management.
Tailoring Approaches for Specific Communities
Rural Native American Communities: Cultivating Culturally Sensitive Research
Research within Rural Native American Communities necessitates a tailored approach, emphasizing diversification of study populations, leveraging local investigators’ community knowledge, and de-emphasizing traditional academic metrics like prior publications and preliminary data in proposal evaluations. Prioritizing partnerships with tribal and undergraduate institutions alongside research-intensive institutions is crucial. Seeking administrative efficiencies and budget flexibility to carry funds across fiscal years can better accommodate the unique needs of community-based research. For remote tribal communities with limited access to healthcare systems, wearable devices present a valuable tool for real-time health monitoring. Secure cloud-based systems can facilitate data recording and patient-friendly display of personal health and wellness measurements, enhancing remote disease management capabilities.
Essential Workers: Addressing Occupational Health Disparities
Essential workers often experience disparities in education, wealth, and income, compounded by occupational disparities that contribute to significant health inequities. During events like the COVID-19 pandemic, essential workers, who are disproportionately from minority groups, face heightened risks and limited ability to work remotely. Mobile technology offers a vital channel for healthcare providers to deliver targeted health messages, appointment reminders, and access to services and information. Developing mobile apps to assess burnout, stress, and cumulative life challenges in essential workers can bolster mental health support and improve overall care management for this vulnerable population.
Nursing Home Residents: Technology for Specialized Care Needs
Nursing home residents present unique healthcare needs that can be effectively addressed by emerging technologies. For example, light-based vein visualization technologies can facilitate blood draws in residents with challenging venous access, addressing a common clinical hurdle, particularly for conditions like anemia management, which require regular blood testing as part of disease management.
Rural Residents: Overcoming Technological Barriers in Rural Healthcare
While smartphone access may be limited among some rural residents, research initiatives can bridge this gap by providing study participants with smartphones for the duration of a study, ensuring equitable access to digital health interventions and research participation. Recognizing the cultural and social nuances, stigmas, and norms within rural communities is crucial for developing culturally sensitive health research programs. Moving beyond broad generalizations about “rural culture” and acknowledging the heterogeneity of rural communities, including regional variations, is essential for advancing effective and targeted rural health research and care management strategies.
Research Study Implications: Adapting Methodologies for Underserved Populations
No-Touch Clinical Trials: Enhancing Accessibility and Inclusivity
The COVID-19 pandemic spurred the development of “no-touch” clinical trial methodologies, bringing trials directly to patients and enhancing accessibility, particularly for remote and underserved populations. E-consent is a critical component of this approach. This patient-centric strategy, adaptable for both devices and treatments, can be tailored for rural and underserved communities, leveraging remote, centralized follow-up mechanisms and supportive materials to ensure inclusivity and effective disease management research.
Addressing Community Mistrust: Building Trust for Research Engagement
While community mistrust can pose a challenge to research studies, many individuals within underserved communities are enthusiastic about participating in research, appreciating the focused attention on their health. Researchers should proactively acknowledge and address community mistrust, demonstrating responsiveness to concerns rather than assuming lack of participation. Open communication and transparent research practices are key to building trust and fostering successful research collaborations.
Facilitating Study Participation: Providing Support and Overcoming Technological Barriers
Challenges in study participation, such as technology unfamiliarity, adherence to device usage, and survey completion, can be mitigated through proactive researcher support. Training staff to build rapport with participants, enlisting tech-savvy family members for assistance, and utilizing screen sharing when possible can enhance participant engagement. Regular follow-up via email or phone calls provides ongoing support and reinforces participation, ensuring data quality and study success, particularly in technology-mediated disease management interventions.
Sleep Research in Underserved Communities: Leveraging Remote Monitoring
Overcoming community skepticism about sleep studies, particularly the use of brainwave monitoring, is essential for advancing sleep health research. Emphasizing the non-invasive nature and informational richness of sleep measurement techniques is crucial. Remote or portable sleep monitoring technology, such as small, patient-friendly devices that monitor breathing position, oxygen saturation, and heart rate, enables researchers to study large groups remotely, including individuals in remote areas without access to sleep laboratories. This expands research opportunities and improves our understanding of sleep health disparities and effective disease management strategies for sleep disorders in underserved populations.
Overcoming Barriers to Disease Management: A Multifaceted Approach
Barriers to effective disease management in underserved populations are multifaceted, encompassing technological literacy, limited cellular/broadband access, and challenges with data integration and interoperability. Opportunities for improvement lie in enhancing home-based point-of-care assessments, expanding remote patient monitoring capabilities, and developing innovative pulmonary rehabilitation approaches. Addressing these barriers and capitalizing on these opportunities through targeted technological and community-based interventions is essential to achieving health equity and improving health outcomes for all.
This workshop underscored the transformative potential of technology to address health disparities and improve healthcare access and outcomes in underserved communities. By focusing on strategic technology deployment, community engagement, and addressing social determinants of health, we can leverage innovation to create a more equitable and effective healthcare system for all.
